February 20, 2006

Arizona Politicians Take Up the Fight Against Rick Moody

The war on class assignments that one or two college students find icky continues.

Sen. Thayer Verschoor introduced the bill after a community college student complained to him after he was assigned to read Rick Moody's The Ice Storm, which contains scenes of sexuality and drug use.

So why doesn't this little whiner do what all other students do instead of read the book - watch the movie. It's superb! Eh, well, there's drug usage in that too, and I suppose seeing a film depiction of drug use might be even more scary and threatening than reading about it. And we wouldn't want to threaten this poor dear by exposing him to something he personally doesn't like. Better not to acknowledge the existence of something - I mean that's what education is all about, right?

On a more practical note for all the profs out there - can you imagine the administrative nightmare and work overload that would result if every single student in all of your classes demanded a syllabus that only fit with their own preexisting beliefs? Quite apart from that gutting the very notion of education, if this were to actually become policy the Arizona state senate better be ready to support huge spending increases in its education budget to pay for all the new professors that will be needed to carry this silliness out to its logical end.

Posted by armand at February 20, 2006 02:12 PM | TrackBack | Posted to The Academy


Comments

And I don't suppose the've thought this through to the logical conclusion that a homosexual wiccan will choose to opt of reading Aquinas in philosophy?

Posted by: binky at February 20, 2006 02:31 PM | PERMALINK

Actually wouldn't this probably require the utter destruction of every philosophy department in the state? Or the creation of about a half dozen such departments at each school with different curricula?

Though I suppose that might be case with a number of disciplines (biology is another obvious example).

Posted by: Armand at February 20, 2006 02:48 PM | PERMALINK

Well, the funny thing is that there are probably a lot more cases where people "fringe" (in the opinion of the people backing this kind of law) religions or sexualities could challenge the dominant cultural tradition that oportunities for mainstream students to challenge "fringe" courses. These people have no idea what is taught in colleges and universities at all.

Posted by: binky at February 20, 2006 02:52 PM | PERMALINK

Wasn't it the people at the fringe who broadened the curriculum in the first place? And while we're at it, how many canonical novels and works of art feature sex and substance abuse, homosexuality, and the rest. They've got degree programs for people who object to this sort of thing -- business administration; communications; accounting. Have fun. Don't let the door hit you . . . .

Posted by: moon at February 20, 2006 05:46 PM | PERMALINK
Post a comment









Remember personal info?