October 06, 2008

Was SNL Anti-Semitic Last Weekend?

Last weekend's skit on the vice presidential debate was super, the best Fey as Palin production yet. But this ... by the end it's definitely not funny, and I can understand arguments that it goes far beyond merely being not funny.

Posted by armand at October 6, 2008 01:16 PM | TrackBack | Posted to Funnies | Media


Comments

So I finally got around to looking at this again (having detected nothing terribly upsetting the first time), and I remain pretty much completely baffled by charges of antisemitism. It probably stopped being funny after the first pair of "baloon mortgage" victims, but that's a taste thing, not an offensive thing. Somebody help me out here.

Posted by: moon at October 11, 2008 11:46 AM | PERMALINK

Well, by making Jewish people like the Sandlers and Soros not merely the winners of this mess, but people who are pulling the world's economic strings in a self-interested and capricious way. Labeling the Sandlers as "people who should be shot" (though I hear NBC has taken that graphic out of the skit now). It does seem to play to stereotypes about "money-grubbing Jews", Jewish conspiracies, and it being legitimate to take up arms against them. I presume those are the problems people have had with the skit (apart from it not being funny).

Posted by: Armand at October 11, 2008 11:56 AM | PERMALINK

I'm pretty sure the waspy yuppies did all right, too. And I didn't even know Soros was Jewish. Unlike the first couple, who were plainly playing up Jewish stage stereotypes in speech patterns and such, nothing about Soros portrayal suggested judaism, real or caricature. I remember, now that you mention it, the "should be shot" graphic when it aired, but I honestly think this one's a reach.

Posted by: moon at October 11, 2008 12:41 PM | PERMALINK
Post a comment









Remember personal info?