February 01, 2006

The T-Shirt Scourge

From the Carpetbagger:

* In August 2004, John Prather, a mild-mannered math professor at Ohio University, was removed by security from a presidential event on public property because he wore a shirt that promoted John Kerry.

* On July 4, 2004, Nicole and Jeff Rank were arrested at a Bush event in West Virginia for wearing T-shirts that criticized the president. (About the same time the Ranks were being taken away in handcuffs, Bush was reminding the audience, "On this 4th of July, we confirm our love of freedom, the freedom for people to speak their minds." Gotta love irony.)

* In August 2004, campaign workers removed a family from a presidential event in Michigan because one woman, a 50-year-old chemist, carried in a rolled-up T-shirt emblazoned with a pro-choice slogan. She later said, "I just wanted to see my president," and brought the extra shirt in case she got cold.

* In July 2004, Jayson Nelson, a county supervisor in Appleton, Wis., was thrown out of a presidential event because of a pro-Kerry T-shirt. An event staffer saw the shirt, snatched the VIP ticket, and called for police. "Look at his shirt! Look at his shirt!" Nelson recalled the woman telling the Ashwaubenon Public Safety officer who answered the call. Nelson said the officer told him, "You gotta go," and sternly directed him to a Secret Service contingent that spent seven or eight minutes checking him over before ejecting him from the property.

* In October 2004, three Oregon schoolteachers were removed from a Bush event and threatened with arrest for wearing t-shirts that said "Protect Our Civil Liberties."

In each instance, the "accused" had tickets to see the president. Moreover, none were disturbing the peace, disrupting the event, or causing a ruckus. Their crime was their shirt.

Posted by binky at February 1, 2006 07:43 PM | TrackBack | Posted to The Ever Shrinking Constitution


Comments

These are all, in my opinion, very bad things, and hopefully unconstitional in a way that a court will one day recognize (though there's the pesky problem of what the Secret Service has to say about security).

But to the extent this is a riff on Sheehan, she simply has no case. Markowitz v. US, 598 A.2d. 398 (D.C. App. 1991) is dispositive. Cohen (Fuck the Draft) doesn't apply to the Capitol, including the galleries.

Posted by: arbitransom at February 1, 2006 11:12 PM | PERMALINK

Really, I could give a rat's patootie about Sheehan in particular. It's bad enough that you have to go through the "ticket to an open air public event" nonsense, but the clothing stuff is a bit much.

Posted by: binky at February 1, 2006 11:25 PM | PERMALINK
Post a comment









Remember personal info?