September 18, 2006

Being Asked if You Are Jewish is "Casting Aspersions"?

Senator Allen (R-VA) responds to a question about whether or not he's Jewish here. Clearly he thinks that he shouldn't be asked that question. Fine. But what I find odd here is that the moderator asked for a simple factual answer - and at the very end of Allen's indignant response you see that apparently he thinks that simply asking him if he's Jewish is "casting aspersions" on him. Hmmmm - racist much? Brendan Nyhan might not call him a racist, even given his history, but it's little wonder that a lot of other people see him that way.

Posted by armand at September 18, 2006 05:20 PM | TrackBack | Posted to Politics


Comments

I despise Allen, but there's a question that the left-blogosphere isn't asking here: why the FUCK was he asked, by the MODERATOR no less, whether his grandfather or great-grandfather or whatever was Jewish? Why the FUCK is this a campaign issue?

Posted by: jacflash at September 19, 2006 07:09 AM | PERMALINK

Hey I think the question is weird too. My best guess is that it's a simple biographical/factual matter that Allen or his campaign had given conflicting responses to, and the question was aimed at clearing that up.

And it as to why ask about any identity or his identity with that - maybe there was an interest in following up with another question tied to Allen's Christianity (a personal affiliation he's more than happy to talk about), or how that affects his interest in protecting oppressed Iraqis ...

Or maybe it was just a random personal thing, a la the revelations that were made about Secretary Albright.

But regardless of why she was asking (and yeah, I was surprised by the question to), I still find his response pretty troubling.

Posted by: Armand at September 19, 2006 07:49 AM | PERMALINK

Allen's challenger apparently has a history of pushing The Jewish Question, which is... interesting.

Posted by: jacflash at September 19, 2006 07:54 AM | PERMALINK

Dana Milbank has a follow-up on this in his Washington Sketch on washingtonpost.com. It seems that the questioner was (supposedly) simply curious about his heritage and seemed to want to pursue a sort of Today Show/US Weekly line (the personal story of ...). Allen seems to have been in a generally annoyed and jumpy (sometimes angry) mood throughout the debate (not just on that question). And ... I don't know. I still find it very odd that he'll publicly talk about his grandfather being arrested by the Nazis, but not the issue of WHY his grandfather was arrested by the Nazis. It still strikes me that he's got some not so pretty personal issues - but that will come as a surprise to no one.

Posted by: Armand at September 19, 2006 12:54 PM | PERMALINK

I posted a comment earlier with links to reports that Allen's challenger has a history of asking/suggesting that opponents are Jewish, but your spamtrap seems to have eaten it and I don't have time to re-dig-up the links. Later, maybe.

Posted by: jacflash at September 19, 2006 02:25 PM | PERMALINK

I just haven't had time today to go through the spam trapper...

Posted by: binky at September 19, 2006 02:28 PM | PERMALINK

And now Allen is "embracing" his newly-discovered Jewish roots. Man, this guy just gets funnier and funnier.

Posted by: jacflash at September 19, 2006 10:29 PM | PERMALINK

Presuming by funnier and funnier you mean odder and odder ... I always wanted him to lose but now I'm REALLY hoping that. This guy is just seriously creeping me out.

Posted by: Armand at September 19, 2006 11:52 PM | PERMALINK

Milbank offers a recap and a tiny bit of perspective today.

And no, I meant "funnier" as in funnier. You think he's getting all discombobulated now, wait until he attempts to run for president.

Posted by: jacflash at September 20, 2006 07:42 AM | PERMALINK
Post a comment









Remember personal info?